Is Mayflower Inn & Spa worth it? Honest pros and cons

Yes — Mayflower Inn & Spa is worth it for travelers looking for a quiet, high-end country retreat with strong spa facilities, quality dining and well-maintained grounds. It may be less compelling if you need budget rates, want a lively nightlife scene, or require extensive child care services.
In this guide
First impressions and setting
Mayflower Inn & Spa sits on 58 acres of landscaped gardens and woodland in Washington, Connecticut, about a two-hour drive from New York City. The property is a restored Dutch Colonial-style inn with formal gardens, a meditation labyrinth and walking trails on-site.
The public rooms and grounds are designed for calm and country-minded elegance rather than high-energy resort activity, making the inn a good match for relaxation, spa time and gentle outdoor pursuits.
- Size: boutique property with 35 guest rooms and suites
- Grounds: Shakespeare Garden, teahouse, pond and walking trails
- Atmosphere: quiet, refined countryside retreat
| Nearby highlights | Drive time (approx.) |
|---|---|
| Steep Rock Preserve | 5–7 minutes |
| Hollister House Garden | About 10 minutes |
| Lake Waramaug | About 10 minutes |

Rooms: comfort, variety and what to expect
Rooms and suites are individually decorated in a traditional country style with canopy or four-poster beds and sitting areas. Room types include Classic Room, Premium Room, Signature Room, Fireplace, Premium Suite, Signature Suite (Library), Suite (Mayflower) and Signature Room.
Expect comfortable king beds, floral or botanical fabrics, window seating and many rooms with garden or lawn views. Bathrooms range from classic double-vanity setups to generous soaking tubs in suites.
- All room types list 1 King Bed as the bed configuration
- Signature Suite (Library) and Suite (Mayflower) are the largest accommodation options
- Standard conveniences: complimentary Wi‑Fi, valet parking and in-room amenities per property policy
| Representative room photos | Style notes |
|---|---|
| Classic Room (photo references exist) | Cozy, some under-eave rooms, window seating |
| Premium Room | Canopy king bed, additional seating and sometimes standalone tubs |
| Signature Suite (Library) | Separate living area with paneled library and fireplace |

Dining: The Garden Room and The Tap Room
Dining at Mayflower is focused on New England countryside cuisine with a Café Boulud residency by Chef Daniel Boulud running through 2026; both The Garden Room and The Tap Room feature Café Boulud-inspired dishes. The Garden Room serves breakfast and lunch daily and a five-course prix fixe dinner Thursday–Saturday, while The Tap Room offers tavern-style dinner nightly.
Meals are not included in standard room rates; breakfast and dinner are available for a fee. Reservations are available via the property's restaurant pages.
- The Garden Room hours: Breakfast 7:30–10:30 AM; Brunch Sat–Sun 10:30 AM–2 PM; Lunch 11 AM–2 PM (Mon–Fri); Café Boulud dinner Thu–Sat 5:30–9:00 PM
- The Tap Room dinner: nightly 5:30–9:00 PM
- Dress code: country casual (no jacket/tie required)
| Venue | Typical service |
|---|---|
| The Garden Room | Breakfast, lunch, select prix fixe dinner |
| The Tap Room | Tavern-style dinner nightly |
Spa and wellness — a strong reason to visit
The Retreat, Wellbeing by Auberge is a large on-site spa with treatment rooms, a greenhouse-style Pool House, a Biophilic Thermal Pool and hammam facilities. Spa access is included in the resort fee and the spa facilities are open daily with treatments requiring advance reservations.
Spa policy restricts access to guests 16 and older for treatments and facilities, so it’s not suitable for young children. Signature treatments and specialized Biologique Recherche facials are offered, and there are both indoor and outdoor wellness features like a barrel sauna.
- Spa access included with the resort fee; reservations required for treatments
- Spa age policy: guests must be 16+ to use the spa
- Facilities include indoor year-round pool, seasonal outdoor pool and steam rooms
| Pool | Availability |
|---|---|
| Indoor spa pool (bromine) | Open year-round |
| Outdoor seasonal pool | Open May–October |

Activities and family friendliness
Mayflower welcomes families and pets (dogs only, up to two per stay, fee applies); the property provides a children's menu, cribs on request and a curated children's book basket. Up to four children age 10 or younger may stay free using existing bedding in a parent or guardian's room.
On-site activities range from croquet and archery to bicycles and walking trails; the resort fee includes bicycle rentals, tennis court access, fitness classes and access to some activities. There is no on-site babysitting service provided by the hotel.
- Family perks: children's menu, cribs available, kids stay free policy (up to 4 under age 11 using existing bedding)
- Pet policy: dogs only, maximum two, $150 per pet per stay (service animals exempt)
- Activities included in resort fee: fitness classes, tennis, bicycle rentals
| Included via resort fee | Notes |
|---|---|
| Wi‑Fi & valet parking | Standard |
| Spa access, fitness classes | Spa treatments cost extra; access included |
| Bicycle and tennis court access | Available seasonally/subject to scheduling |
Events, weddings and meetings
Mayflower Inn & Spa offers a variety of indoor and outdoor event spaces — from the Shakespeare Garden and Teahouse to the Wicker Porch, Tap Room and Library — with capacities ranging from intimate dinners to gatherings up to about 150 guests. The property handles event planning and offers meeting amenities like A/V and on-site coordinators.
For large events, the inn can be booked in part or fully; some wedding packages and buyout options are described by third-party planners, and event inquiries go through the hotel's event contact channels.
- Event venues include Shakespeare Garden (up to ~150), Teahouse (75 reception), Tap Room (50), Garden Room (25) and Library (6)
- Event services: on-site event coordinator, catering through the inn's restaurants, A/V and meeting support
- Capacity flexibility: options for small private dinners up to tented receptions
| Venue | Max reception capacity |
|---|---|
| Shakespeare Garden | 150 |
| Event Tent | 150 |
| Teahouse | 75 |
Price, fees and practicalities
The property charges a per-accommodation resort fee that includes Wi‑Fi, valet parking, a welcome beverage, morning coffee/tea, spa access, tennis and some activities. Meals, treatments and certain services are extra, and the inn accepts major credit cards but does not accept cash.
Check-in is 4:00 PM and check-out is 12:00 PM (noon). A photo ID and credit card are required at check-in. Transport options include an airport shuttle for a surcharge and private car services on request.
- Resort fee: $58 per accommodation, per night (does not change seasonally)
- Payment: American Express, Discover, Mastercard, Visa (no cash)
- Check-in/out: check-in 4:00 PM; check-out noon
| Service | Included or extra |
|---|---|
| Spa treatments | Extra (reservations required) |
| Breakfast & dinner | Extra (restaurant fees apply) |
| Valet parking & Wi‑Fi | Included via resort fee |


